Personnel Policy Service, Inc.

about us > hr management articles > Benefits > Cafeteria Plans


intelligent search resultsintelligent search resultsimagine it. Search!
  HR Matters E-Tips

Free Weekly Newsletter

Quick Read
Policy Guidelines
Compliance Analysis
Click here for a sample.
 
Email Address 
First Name
Last Name
 

We respect your privacy.

 
 
  FREE HR Policies
· Attendance
· COBRA Requirements
· Dress Code
· Drugs/Narcotics/Alcohol
· Employee Classification
· FLSA Compliance
· FMLA Checklist
· Workplace Smoking
· Holiday
· Internet/Email Communication
· Layoff and Recall
· Military Leave
· Pay Procedures
· Rest Breaks
· Sexual Harassment
 
 
 
  Contact Us

Email: info@ppspublishers.com
Site: www.ppspublishers.com
       www.instanthrpolicies.com
 
 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3 FREE Issues
!!!
HR Matters Monthly Newsletter
New Electronic Version - or print
* 800# HR Answerline - live expert help in solving daily emergencies
* Plain-English alerts and analysis - puts you ahead of new legal issues
* Solid background documentation to justify and support decisions
* Timely action steps to avoid unpleasant surprises and mistakes
* Nuts-and-bolts HR "best practices" to build your credibility and career
 
To request your 3 f-r-e-e issues of HR Matters newsletter, click here.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

INCONSISTENT DISCIPLINE CAN RESULT IN DISCRIMINATION CLAIMS

Consistent discipline means that employees who commit similar offenses in similar situations receive the same consequence. Determining when situations are similar is tricky, but a recent court decision emphasizes the importance of careful consideration in any disciplinary action.

An anxiety-provoking aspect of disciplining employees is the worry that if the consequences seem arbitrary, you may face discrimination charges. Ironically, that concern may actually lead some employers to apply discipline unevenly by disciplining employees who are not in legally protected classes more severely than other employees. A recent case from the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals demonstrates how inconsistent discipline can create an inference of discrimination. In Lynn v. Deaconess Medical Center-West Campus, 160 F.3d 484 (8th Cir. 1998), the court determined that a male employee’s offenses were comparable to those of a similarly situated female employee and that he may have been discriminated against because of his sex since he was disciplined more harshly.

Male Nurse Disciplined More Harshly Than Female
In Lynn, the trouble began when a male nurse had a series of run-ins with his supervisor for lying on a couch and watching television during his shift. His supervisor verbally counseled him after the incident. Subsequent minor work rule violations by the employee led to more verbal discipline, followed by three disciplinary letters. Surprisingly, his supervisor did not mention this series of disciplinary action in his annual performance review, which noted only that the misconduct had ceased and that his performance was satisfactory. A few months after that review, the male nurse received two more disciplinary letters for failing to follow work procedures, followed by a recommendation for his discharge. He was given the option to resign and he did.

He then filed a sex discrimination lawsuit under Title VII based primarily on inconsistent discipline. He alleged that he was disciplined more severely than a female nurse who slept on the job and whose offenses continued for eleven months before she received written discipline. The lower court ruled in favor of the employer, deciding that the male nurse and his female colleague were not similarly situated because the male nurse’s personnel file contained more disciplinary records and his offenses differed from those committed by the female nurse.

Court Rules Male Nurse May Have Been Discriminated Against
The Court of Appeals disagreed with the lower court and determined that the male nurse and his female colleague were similarly situated and that the male nurse had sufficient evidence for a jury to consider a sex discrimination charge against the employer. In finding that the male and female employees were similarly situated, this court looked at the nature and the severity of the offenses committed by both employees and found they were comparable offenses. In addition, the court pointed out that the employer should have compared the male and female nurses’ situations to be sure it was administering the same level of discipline for similar offenses. For these reasons, the court decided that the case should go to trial based on the employee’s evidence that he was disciplined more severely than the female employee for offenses that were less serious.

Consistent Discipline Considers Situation and Offense
This case illustrates the consequences of not disciplining employees consistently. Consistent discipline does not mean that employers must apply the exact same discipline and follow the exact same procedures for each employee. Rather, as the court found in this case, employers should try to treat "similarly situated" employees in the same manner. This court looked at comparable offenses to determine whether the employees were similarly situated. Other criteria that courts consider for similarly situated employees are past performance and disciplinary records, job duties, length of employment, and status or position within the organization.

A second lesson from this case is that employers should document disciplinary actions consistently. The male employee’s performance review characterized his performance as satisfactory and did not reflect his offenses or the disciplinary action taken. Thus, the performance review made the employer’s subsequent termination decision less credible and instead may have supported the employee’s contention that he was disciplined more harshly because he was male. Therefore, employers should document the reasons for administering discipline in employee files so that performance reviews, disciplinary records, and notes in the files all reflect the same disciplinary issues.

A final lesson is that although it’s uncommon, men can sue for sex discrimination.

For more information on disciplinary policy, see Disciplinary Procedure, Chapter 808.

 

This article is not intended as legal advice. Readers are encouraged to seek appropriate legal or other professional advice. Copyright 2004 Personnel Policy Service, Inc.

 

Use FREE for 30 Days

Personnel Policy Manual Service
     
Available in Print or CD-ROM

At Personnel Policy Service, we've put together all the resources you need for clear answers to employment law compliance - including toll-free access to HR experts for individualized support. This comprehensive time-and-money saving service will help you:

  • create and update personnel policies, 

  • put together employee handbooks,

  • write procedures and training guides,

  • look up HR best practices and trends,

  • protect yourself from liability, 

  • stay on top of U.S. employment regulations,

  • avoid unnecessary lawsuits, and

  • build your policy and compliance expertise 

See first-hand how the Personnel Policy Manual service will quickly become your most important business partner. Use the service free for 30 days. At the end of 30 days, either pay the invoice to continue service, or simply return the manual and owe nothing. There are no contracts, so there's no risk.

HR Manual Service - Get Personnel Policy Manual, Monthly HR Policy Updates, Monthly HR Matters Newsletter, HR Answerline Telephone support, HR Matters Etips newsletter.
$437/yr.

100% Money Back
Guarantee of Satisfaction
Good for a FULL YEAR!

If you'd like to know more about the five-part service, click on the links below. 

 

Subscription includes:

To use the Personnel Policy Manual Service free for 30 days, just fill in the form below and submit.  Or call our friendly customer service department at 1-800-437-3735. 

Fill out this form and submit:

* indicates required fields

                 Choose Format

Print
CD (Why CD? Click here)
Review both: Print & CD
   
*First Name
*Last Name
*Title
*Organization

*Street address

Address (Cont)
*City
*State/Province   *Zip/Postal Code
Country
*Work Phone    Ext.
*FAX
*E-mail
*Number of Employees
FREE OFFER:

        

HR Matters E-Tips is a free weekly e-mail that gives  you quick, easy-to-read, sound advice on HR topics. You'll be signed up automatically. If you choose not to receive this free HR advice, uncheck the box below.

Please sign me up to receive HR Matters E-Tips.
It's free and I can cancel any time.
Would you like to get information and special offers about HR products and services?

Yes, keep me informed

 
 

Use Free for 30 Days!

(Service Available in Print or CD)

Personnel Policy Manual

Solid legal information.

Sound policy advice.

Solutions you can rely on.

Bonus:

Toll-free HR support

  Use Free for 30 Days! Click here.
 

Easy Employee Handbook

Instant HR Policies

Software has 69 everyday

HR policies. Use 'as is' or

modify for your situation.

Ideal for creating employee

handbooks and manuals.

Approved by attorneys.

Easy to use. Affordable.

Download! Click here.

 

Policy Writing & Decision Making Kits

Absence
Attendance and Punctuality
Short-Term Absences
Leaves of Absence
Rest Breaks
Meal Breaks
Benefits
Disclosure of Benefits
Vacations
Holidays
Lunch Facilities
Educational Assistance
Employee Counseling
Recognition Awards
Company Products
Relocation
Athletics and Recreation
Conduct
Behavior of Employees
Appearance of Employees
Finances of Employees
Customer Relations
Use of Communications
Conflicts of Interest
Confidentiality
Disciplinary Procedure
Drugs, Narcotics, Alcohol
Employment
Equal Employment Opportunity
Sexual Harassment
Hiring
Employment Agreements
Orientation and Training
Medical Procedures
Serious Diseases
Introductory Period
Transfer
Promotion
Hours of Work
Outside Employment
Employee Classifications
Layoff and Recall
Termination
Retirement
Miscellaneous
Personnel Records
Community Participation
Suggestion Program
Dispute Resolution
Pay Practices
Salary Administration
Performance Appraisals
Severance Pay
Job Evaluation
Pay Procedures
Personnel Responsibilities
Model Cover
President’s Letter
Functions of this Manual
Employee Supervision
Personnel Manager
Employer-Employee Relations
Employment-At-Will
Reimbursement
Travel
Automobile Usage
Business Entertaining
Meal Reimbursement
Clubs and Civic Organizations
Trade and Professional Associations
Work Areas
Employee Safety
Maintenance of Work Areas
Personal Property
Solicitation
Parking
Security
Smoking
Special Reports
2004 FLSA Regulations: Understanding the Issues

To see complete table of contents, click on the policy.

 

Employment Law Video Training Program

Award-winning Employment Law training - "Ten Danger Zones for  Supervisors"

 

▪ Hiring ▪ Evaluations & Discipline Discrimination ▪ Violence ▪  Firing 

▪ FMLA ▪ Harassment ▪

Accidents ▪ Privacy 

Click here for Special Discount

 

  Free Download Center

Our HR expertise and

attention to legal detail

is first-rate. Visit our free

download center and see

for yourself.

  Free Policies. Click here.
 
 
 
 
     

Employee  Manual | HR Matters newsletter | HR Compliance Tips | Employee Manual (CD-ROM)
Easy to Create Employee Handbook | Management & Compliance  Tips| Human Resource Management | Resource Links | Employment Law