Personnel Policy Service, Inc.

about us > hr management articles > ADA > Stress-Free Workplace


HR Policy & Compliance Experts Since 1972

  HR Matters E-Tips

Free Weekly Newsletter

Quick Read
Policy Guidelines
Compliance Analysis
Click here for a sample.
 
Email Address 
First Name
Last Name
 

We respect your privacy.

 
 
  FREE HR Policies
· Attendance
· COBRA Requirements
· Dress Code
· Drugs/Narcotics/Alcohol
· Employee Classification
· FLSA Compliance
· FMLA Checklist
· Workplace Smoking
· Holiday
· Internet/Email Communication
· Layoff and Recall
· Military Leave
· Pay Procedures
· Rest Breaks
· Sexual Harassment
 
 
 
  Contact Us

Email: info@ppspublishers.com
Site: www.ppspublishers.com
       www.instanthrpolicies.com

Twitter @ppshrpolicies

 
 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3 FREE Issues
!!!
HR Matters Monthly Newsletter
New Electronic Version - or print
* 800# HR Answerline - live expert help in solving daily emergencies
* Plain-English alerts and analysis - puts you ahead of new legal issues
* Solid background documentation to justify and support decisions
* Timely action steps to avoid unpleasant surprises and mistakes
* Nuts-and-bolts HR "best practices" to build your credibility and career
 
To request your 3 f-r-e-e issues of HR Matters newsletter, click here.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Stress-Free Workplace Not A Reasonable Accommodation Under the ADA

The Facts
The Court’s Decision
Lesson for Employers

An employer does not have to provide a stress-free working environment as a reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act ("ADA"), the Third Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in Gaul v. Lucent Technologies, No. 97-5114, 1/22/98. Upholding the district court’s decision of summary judgment for Lucent Technologies (formerly part of AT&T), the Third Circuit determined that the employee failed to demonstrate that his request for a stress-free workplace was a reasonable accommodation.

The Facts
Dennis Gaul worked as a technical associate for AT&T from 1981 to 1992. During this time, he was treated for depression and anxiety-related disorders and took two disability leaves of absence. Following the second leave, Gaul was assigned to work on development of a new product. From the beginning of the new assignment, Gaul had conflicts with his coworker, claiming the coworker refused to share necessary information with him, unfairly used information from Gaul’s database, and did not acknowledge Gaul’s contributions to the project. Attempts to resolve the conflict with the coworker and various supervisors were unsuccessful. Gaul requested a transfer to a job where he would not be stressed by coworkers. Neither Gaul nor his supervisor followed up on the transfer request, and two weeks later in September 1992, Gaul took disability leave. Gaul filed suit in 1994, alleging disability discrimination under the ADA because AT&T did not accommodate him by transferring him to a position where he would not be subjected to "prolonged and inordinate stress" by coworkers. The district court granted AT&T’s motion for summary judgment, and Gaul appealed.

The Court’s Decision

The Third Circuit affirmed the district court’s decision because Gaul did not demonstrate that the benefits associated with the proposed transfer would outweigh its costs. In its decision, the court focused on the difficulty that AT&T would have in providing a working environment without "prolonged and inordinate stress." The court identified three factors for denying the accommodation: (1) Gaul’s proposed accommodation would impose an impractical obligation on the employer; (2) Gaul’s request would require the employer to consider his stress level when assigning him to projects; and (3) Gaul was asking the court to establish the conditions of his employment with AT&T. Because the court determined that the accommodations request was unreasonable, it declined to rule if the employee was disabled under the ADA.

Lesson for Employers

This case is a favorable decision for employers since it establishes that a stress-free workplace generally is not a reasonable accommodation under the ADA. Under the ADA, employers must provide reasonable accommodation so the employee can perform the essential functions of the job. However, employers do not have to provide the accommodation if it would create an unreasonable burden.

In this decision, the court seemed reluctant to require the employer to make an accommodation that would involve continual monitoring and readjustment of a hard-to-define standard, i.e, whether the employee was exposed to "prolonged and inordinate stress." In addition, the court refused to usurp the employer’s authority to assign employees by determining where the employee should work within the organization.

For more information, contact the federal Job Accommodation Network ("JAN") at 1-800-526-7234 or visit the web site at http://www.jan.wvu.edu.

 

This article is not intended as legal advice. Readers are encouraged to seek appropriate legal or other professional advice.

 
Try a Free No-Risk 30-Day Trial Review Now
Personnel Policy Manual Service
Your HR policy solution for writing, revision, and legal compliance
Try a Free, No-Risk 30-Day Trial Review Now
(No Credit Card Required)

See why so many call it their “HR Policy Bible”
Available in Print (917 page binder) and/or Online
 

Unprecedented changes impacting HR
Today’s economic, political, and employment environment is more unsettled for human resources professionals than any time we’ve seen in our 37 years of advising employers. As a result, you need much more than news and raw information – you need clear advice and guidance on what to do … and when.

A complete support system
And, that’s where the Personnel Policy Manual System fits in. It’s like having an extra HR expert and employment law specialist on your staff – for less than the cost of a cup of coffee per day. You get in one place the total policy and compliance support you need and want.

Look at the new compliance challenges you already have for 2009:
-- Changes to COBRA
-- The new Ledbetter Fair Pay Act
-- Amendments to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
-- New Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) regulations
-- Labor Secretary promising to step up FLSA & FMLA enforcement

And there’s even more that should be on your radar screen:
-- Regulations for the new ADA Amendments
-- The Employee Free Choice Act
-- The Paycheck Fairness Act
-- The Healthy Families Act
-- The Employment Non-Discrimination Act
-- FMLA Amendments expanding coverage to smaller employers
-- New minimum wage increases beyond what’s scheduled

You can still stay ahead with a complete policy and compliance system:
Take a test drive of the Personnel Policy Manual System and see for yourself why so many of our subscribers refer to it as their “HR Policy Bible.” In one turnkey package, you’ll find:

  • Updated and ready-to-go sample policies, complete with supporting HR background and best practices – plus compliance analysis and over 1500 legal citations

  • Continuous updating and supplementation to stay on top of needed changes

  • Monthly HR Matters newsletter for professional insights and recommended action steps

  • Weekly HR Matters E-Tips for practical tips to solve daily problems

Risk-free – try before you buy (no advance credit card required)
Don’t take our word for it. Check out the Personnel Policy Manual System for 30 days and see for yourself. You pay nothing unless totally satisfied. At the end of 30 days, either pay the invoice to continue your annual subscription, or simply return the Manual (or cancel the Online) and owe nothing.

Annual Subscription Price: $477 – after the trial
At the end of your risk-free trial, you make the decision whether to continue for the annual subscription of $477. Even then, you still take no risk because we have an iron-clad satisfaction guarantee: if change your mind at any time in the first 12 months after you’ve paid, just return the materials and we will refund 100% of your payment. It’s that safe.

To request your 30-day, risk-free trial, just fill in the form below and click “Start Free Trial.” Or, call our friendly customer service at 1-800-437-3735 (9:00-5:00 Eastern Time). We’ll be happy to process your request, answer questions, or schedule a quick 10-minute Online Demonstration.

Fill out this form and submit:
* indicates required fields

Here's What's Included:

* 900-page HR Reference System
   (print/CD)
*
Monthly updates
*
Monthly HR Matters newsletter
*
Weekly HR Matters E-Tips

 

View Sample HR Policy

 

100% Money Back
Guarantee of Satisfaction
Good for a FULL YEAR!

 

Less than 15 employees? OR
Outside US? Click here

Format:
Print
Online
Both Print and Online
First:
Last:
Title:
Business or Organization:
Street Address:
Street Address 2:
City:
State:
Zip Code:
Business Phone:
Business Fax:
Email:
Number of Employees:
 

 

 
 

Use Free for 30 Days!

(Service Available in Print or CD)

Personnel Policy Manual

Solid legal information.

Sound policy advice.

Solutions you can rely on.

Bonus:

Toll-free HR support

  Use Free for 30 Days! Click here.
 

Easy Employee Handbook

Instant HR Policies

Software has 69 everyday

HR policies. Use 'as is' or

modify for your situation.

Ideal for creating employee

handbooks and manuals.

Approved by attorneys.

Easy to use. Affordable.

Download! Click here.

 

Policy Writing & Decision Making Kits

Absence
Attendance and Punctuality
Short-Term Absences
Leaves of Absence
Rest Breaks
Meal Breaks
Benefits
Disclosure of Benefits
Vacations
Holidays
Lunch Facilities
Educational Assistance
Employee Counseling
Recognition Awards
Company Products
Relocation
Athletics and Recreation
Conduct
Behavior of Employees
Appearance of Employees
Finances of Employees
Customer Relations
Use of Communications
Conflicts of Interest
Confidentiality
Disciplinary Procedure
Drugs, Narcotics, Alcohol
Employment
Equal Employment Opportunity
Sexual Harassment
Hiring
Employment Agreements
Orientation and Training
Medical Procedures
Serious Diseases
Introductory Period
Transfer
Promotion
Hours of Work
Outside Employment
Employee Classifications
Layoff and Recall
Termination
Retirement
Miscellaneous
Personnel Records
Community Participation
Suggestion Program
Dispute Resolution
Pay Practices
Salary Administration
Performance Appraisals
Severance Pay
Job Evaluation
Pay Procedures
Personnel Responsibilities
Model Cover
President’s Letter
Functions of this Manual
Employee Supervision
Personnel Manager
Employer-Employee Relations
Employment-At-Will
Reimbursement
Travel
Automobile Usage
Business Entertaining
Meal Reimbursement
Clubs and Civic Organizations
Trade and Professional Associations
Work Areas
Employee Safety
Maintenance of Work Areas
Personal Property
Solicitation
Parking
Security
Smoking
Special Reports
2004 FLSA Regulations: Understanding the Issues

To see complete table of contents, click on the policy.

 

Employment Law Video Training Program

Award-winning Employment Law training - "Ten Danger Zones for  Supervisors"

 

▪ Hiring ▪ Evaluations & Discipline Discrimination ▪ Violence ▪  Firing 

▪ FMLA ▪ Harassment ▪

Accidents ▪ Privacy 

Click here for Special Discount

 

  Free Download Center

Our HR expertise and

attention to legal detail

is first-rate. Visit our free

download center and see

for yourself.

  Free Policies. Click here.
 
 
 
 
     

Employee  Manual | HR Matters newsletter | HR Compliance Tips | Employee Manual (CD-ROM)
Easy to Create Employee Handbook | Management & Compliance  Tips| Human Resource Management | Resource Links | Employment Law